Skip to content
Saturday, September 26, 202668 days to the Dice Letter centennialNo physics degree or shared belief required.
GOD PLAYS DICE™The magazine of big questions

LIFE IN THE UNIVERSE EXPLAINER

Are We Alone in the Universe?

Planets are common. Evidence of life beyond Earth has yet to be confirmed.

Artist’s illustration of the TRAPPIST-1 star and seven labeled planets arranged in a row.
Artist’s illustration of the TRAPPIST-1 system. The planets have not been photographed this way, and no life has been found there.NASA, JPL/Caltech, and R. Hurt and T. Pyle (IPAC)Image source ↗

We do not know whether life exists beyond Earth. That answer may feel disappointing, but it sits beside a remarkable discovery: planets are common. Astronomers have confirmed thousands of worlds orbiting other stars, and the search has moved from wondering whether planets exist elsewhere to asking which ones might offer conditions in which life could arise.

A planet in a “habitable zone” is at a distance from its star where liquid water might exist on its surface under the right conditions. That phrase is a useful first filter, not a certificate that the world is habitable, much less inhabited. An atmosphere, the star’s behavior, the planet’s history, and many other details matter. We cannot look at an orbit alone and announce an ocean or a living organism.

How might we learn more? For some planets, astronomers study the light that has passed through or been emitted by an atmosphere. The pattern can suggest which gases are present. A gas sometimes associated with life on Earth might be interesting, but one clue can have more than one cause. NASA’s astrobiology strategy emphasizes context and multiple lines of evidence because nonliving processes can imitate a proposed sign of life. A promising measurement would begin an investigation, not finish it.

Closer to home, researchers also study places in our solar system that may hold water and useful chemistry. The basic question is similar: What was measured, and how securely does that measurement point to life? A photograph of a strange landscape, an organic molecule, or a potentially favorable environment is not the same thing as finding a living cell. Each discovery changes what we know about possible habitats even if it does not answer the larger question.

There is another jump people often make. “Life elsewhere” includes the possibility of microbes. It does not automatically mean intelligent life, visiting spacecraft, or a civilization trying to contact us. Each claim calls for different evidence. We can be open to all of them while keeping those categories separate. Saying that extraterrestrial life is possible expresses a reasonable scientific question; saying it has been found requires a finding that others can examine and test.

NASA’s public account is direct: despite the abundance of planets, we have no evidence of life beyond Earth so far. That statement may change one day. If it does, the strongest announcement will be accompanied by measurements, competing explanations, and independent scrutiny. Until then, the vastness of space is a reason to keep looking and a reason to resist filling the silence with certainty.

Sources & further reading

  1. NASA Science — Are We Alone? ↗
  2. NASA Astrobiology Strategy 2018 — Biosignatures and multiple lines of evidence ↗

#Astrobiology#Exoplanets

KEEP ASKING

If a telescope found a gas linked to life in one planet’s atmosphere, what other explanations would you want ruled out?